Three realities coaches can't ignore

Research

By Connor Sharp

Three Realities Coaches Can't Ignore

"There is numerical evidence that young people are experiencing harm while they take part in sport and the first thing we have to do as coaches is sort that out"

These were the words by MVMT sports founder Simon Turner on a recent Zoom call with coaches.

Recognising that people experience harm while engaging in sports can be an uncomfortable and difficult process for many. But that doesn't mean it should be ignored. Recognising that people experience harm in sport is the first step to addressing the problem.

This blog post aims to help and enhance your understanding of the harm sport causes. We will share with you three key insights supported by research evidence.

Here are 3 realities about sport that coaches can't ignore.

1. Players are experiencing harm (even if you can't see it)

At MVMT we support dozens of coaches and sports development professionals to learn the process of creating both sporting results and social outcomes at the same time.

We have found consistently that coaches focus heavily on the difference they can make for the people they coach, with little focus on the impact they can have on a wider community and often neglect the impact their coaching has on themselves.

A 2011 study commissioned by the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC) in the United Kingdom showed that harmful experiences in sport are not limited to a small minority of participants. This graph provides an overview of the types of harm young people experienced based on the evidence from the study.

Harm in Sport

This shows that at least 3 out 4 of young people in sport have experienced harm, with 75% of participants of the study reporting emotional harm. Other types of harm and abuse while not as common are still happening at a concerning rate. These figures confirm that address the harm should be a focus for all coaches.

2. A narrow identity is more dangerous than competition

The NSPCC research found that coach's role in causing harm "increased as young athletes advanced through the competitive ranks". But increased levels of competition doesn't have to mean increased emotional harm.

A recent study in the Journal of Sports Sciences compared the psychosocial outcomes of young people who engaged with football recreationally to same-age elite players who attended a football academy. The study found that the psychosocial outcomes were similar and that academy involvement didn't have a negative impact on this.

However what the same study did find is that academy players reported a greater athletic identity compared to the more recreational athletes. This posses some risk as a narrow and one-dimensional identity can have a range of negative consequences in the short-and long- term as people inevitably encounter setbacks in sport (e.g. injuries or failing to progress to the next competitive rank). At this point, when the athletic identity is taken away, individuals may feel lost in the absence of any other identity, source of esteem or motive.

3. With trust comes responsibility

Coaches have some degree of responsibility in creating a safe sporting environment. This is a responsibility they share with each an every other individual with an interest in sport, such as parents or sport administrators. While the responsibility is shared, sport academics argue that coaches have a particular responsibility because:

Parents, administrators, and athletes at all levels place an extraordinary amount of trust in sport coaches and expect sport organizations and administrators to implement and understand child protection measures as well as ensure that the need to assist victims supersedes their desire to protect their program

Research in the European Journal for Sport and Society shows that 95% of athletes trust their coaches. Athletes trust their coaches to protect them from harm and so it's important for coaches to honour that trust and focus on doing just that. This means going the extra mile and not making assumptions. The NSPCC research shows that coaches can directly contribute to harm or even do so indirectly by condoning, ignoring or not dealing with harmful behaviour effectively. They could be doing this without even knowing. As a coach being ignorant to harm is no excuse.

3 Takeaways for Coaches

1. Get anonymous data on your team

Harm is happening in sport. It's happening without coaches even seeing it. This is why as a coach you need to question your environment. Challenge your assumptions within your team or club. Judge your environment on data, not just your experience.

Harm is a sensitive subject and not something everyone is comfortable or capable of discussing openly. Getting feedback anonymously helps address this problem. Allowing anonymous feedback can help protect the victims of harm while equipping coaches with the awareness they need to address the harm in their environment.

This can easily be done by creating an online survey and sharing this with players and parents.

2. Get feedback from those who leave

Your current players are not the only people who can provide valuable feedback. What about the people who leave? Do you have an exit survey with players who quit your team or sport?

Sport should be inclusive and accessible. If you don't know what might be driving players to leave you won't be able to address these problems. Don't just assume. Actively seek out feedback, whether its good or bad.

Try setting up an exit survey form for players (or parents) that enables them to share their views before they leave for good. Or, reach out to former players (not the ones you know already think positively of you) and ask for honest feedback.

3. Train yourself in mental health first aid

Eliminating harm for sport will not be easy. But there are things that you can do on an individual level that can make a big difference. One of them is to train in mental health first aid.

As noted above, a majority of the harm that happens in sport is emotional. Coaches all over the world can take a Mental Health First Aid course. Becoming a Mental Health First Aider can help you protect the players you coach and go a long way in creating a safer environment.

A mental wellbeing crisis is on the horizon and coaches have to adapt as a result.

Additional resources

The Child Protection in Sport Unit

UK Coaching - Duty to Care Toolkit and Digital Badge

SafeSport (USA)

References

British Journal of Sports Medicine - International Olympic Committee consensus statement: harassment and abuse (non-accidental violence) in sport

European Journal for Sport and Society - Sexual harassment and abuse in coach-athlete relationships in Sweden

Journal of Sport Sciences - Psychological outcomes associated with soccer academy involvement: Longitudinal comparisons against aged matches school pupils

NSPCC Research - The experiences of children participating in organised sport in the UK (Summary Report)

Satore-Baldwin, McCullough and Quatman-Yates - Shared responsibility and issues of injustice and harm within sport

Be a difference maker

Each week we send an email to coaches with one reflection question. It’s a short and easy way to bring clarity and purpose to your coaching. Sign up below (but only if you put people before winning).

Tools for coaches

At MVMT sports, we make the ‘tools of the trade’ for coaches who want to be difference makers. Our practice planning tools for football and basketball enable coaches to speed up the plan-do-review process and become difference makers for the people they coach.

Written by Connor Sharp

Twitter

LinkedIn

 

Join a movement of difference makers

We’re on a mission to help coaches use sport as a movement for good (not bad).

Our short weekly emails pose questions that will help you to understand your coaching, understand yourself and understand the people you coach.  

Enter your email address to join us

(but only if you put people first).

Value is required
Thanks for joining the movement!

Who we are

We're a mission-driven business for people who believe sport should be a movement for good (not bad).

What we do

We make the 'tools of the trade' for difference maker coaches.

Blog posts

The MVMT blog profiles difference maker coaches. Each week we ask challenging questions and share key takeaways that bring clarity and purpose to your coaching.

Read our blog here

Blog posts

The MVMT blog profiles difference maker coaches. Each week we ask challenging questions and share key takeaways that bring clarity and purpose to your coaching.

Read our blog here

Join a movement of difference makers

Value is required
You've joined a movement of difference makers.

Older Post Newer Post